Guess what happens when the reader is reading your sales pitch and encounters something that feels too good to be true? That’s right, it’s an immediate credit card block. But why is that?

The Biological Basis for Too Good to Be True

For tens of thousands of years, humans lived in an unpredictable world. Dangers outnumbered safety. Our brains evolved to be overly cautious. Imagine you are part of a tribe that depends on hunting. Your people are starving, you haven’t eaten in days. You’ve been scouting and haven’t seen a single animal. This is highly unusual. Then, on a desperate hunting trip, you spot a dead animal. It’s right there. What are the odds? Normally, even if you spot something, you would have the impossible task of bringing it down. Most of the time the animal was smart enough to escape.

Anyway, now you are staring at an uneaten animal. This seems too good to be true. Maybe it is. Maybe this animal was sick. If you eat it, your tribe might get sick and die. Why haven’t the hyenas been gnawing on this carcass? That seems very odd.

So while part of you is deliriously happy, it also seems highly unusual; too good to be true!

What would you do?

Those types of life decisions are much rarer now but our brains have not adapted as quickly as our environment. That self-protective mechanism is still deeply embedded in our operating mechanism. Now we just use it for online shopping decisions.

“We have become so accustomed to hearing everyone claim that his product is the best in the world, or the cheapest, that we take all such statements with a grain of salt.” – Robert Collier

Marketer’s Job

So this is what’s at stake. For the shopper, a “too good to be true” claim is a very risky proposition. It’s true that the downside of a wrong decision is minimal (they could return the item or cancel the order on their credit card) but the mental conflict is just as intense as it was for our hunting ancestors 50,000 years ago.

The secret super power of a great marketer is massive empathy. A good marketer can feel what the online shopper is feeling. When the online shopper salivates the good marketer senses it; when the shopper struggles the good marketer feels it.

The job of the marketer is to remove every instance of too good to be true from the shopping funnel. Starting from awareness stage to interest stage to desire stage to the action stage.

If the shopper senses too good to be true at any of these points, they will abandon.

To prevent this, the marketer needs to retrace the shopper’s journey and evaluate every word to see if it could be viewed as too good to be true. If any part of the entire journey can, then the marketer needs to craft a message to allay this feeling.

Making the Marketer’s Life Harder

It’s not easy being a marketer. You have to get into the heads of your visitors and see the world as they see it. Feel the things they feel. Ask the questions they ask. When a shopper encounters something that seems too good to be true, they don’t send you an email to ask for an explanation or call customer service to understand exactly how your motor can be 60% more efficient than the competition. It would be awesome if shoppers did that. Do you know what they do? They say, “I call BS and leave for your site forever”. This is why solving this is so important: you’ve already spent a lot of money to get visitors to your site and designed a site to engage them. Don’t lose them at the last step.

Example— Solving Too Good to Be True

We all hate popups. This is a great newsletter signup pitch. It makes a claim (+45% open rate) and backs it up:

Next Steps

Now that Too Good to Be True is clear you need to master the next item in our conversion optimization checklist: Shoppers find expertise sexy.