Comments 20

  1. Google had stated (when SearchWiki came out) that they don’t take click-through rates into their natural algorithm at “this time”, unlike PPC. If they changed their stance recently they wouldn’t be telling us. Maybe it’s worth a test, but because it is artificial, Google would probably come up with a work around sooner than later.

    1. Post

      Hi Bill,

      You are right, this strategy assumes Google DOES consider click-through. I have no clue what all Google factors. Here is my question: What do you mean by artificial? How would Google discern this is artificial? I’d love to hear your thoughts.


  2. Fascinating idea – very clever! The big issue I see with it, as some of those who commented on the post mentioned, is that if this were to become a standard practice in email campaigns, Google would have to alter it’s algorithm to counter the impact it was having on its SERPs. And the marketers with the biggest in-house email lists could really exploit it to ensure they maintained their ranking – impacting the ability of the small players to move up the rankings. Nevertheless, an interesting idea.

  3. Brilliant idea! I agree with Jim, if Google places more on Click Throughs, larger companies could take real advantage of this. Better yet, it is a great way to build some links for that keyword to your site which would again improve rankings. Nice 🙂

  4. Spoke with a friend of mine about this idea (since it intrigued me so much). Here’s what he said: if Google notices significant spikes in any kind of activity they track (and one wonders these days what they’re not tracking), they will investigate it. Relevance, after all, is their mantra. If they conclude it’s got a sniff of gaming/black(or gray) hat associated with it, they will react. His suggestion: better to embed the concept in the blogs/social networks which Google crawls and use the links to increase Page Rank for the site.

    1. Post
  5. From purely an SEO perspective, this influx of traffic to your page will not generally improve your ranking for this term, although I think the idea is very intriguing from a marketing stand point. However, Google now uses personalized search. And although I don’t know their algorithm, I would bet that click-thrus would improve the sites ranking for related terms next time one of the people who received the e-mail typed in a query like “gourmet chocolate popcorn.”

    I don’t see how it would directly impact anyone else. If you think about it, driving traffic to this page does not in any way tell Google that the page is more relevant for the specific term “gourmet chocolate popcorn.” The traffic might make Google notice that the page is important overall, although I can’t confirm this.

    If you want to improve your ranking for this term (because you already know that it converts well), you need to make sure it’s optimized well and more importantly, you need your strategy to include quality, related links back to this page. These links are seen as votes, which is why you see how powerful domain like wikipedia are (they rank for everything!).

    Now, if people spread your e-mail and linkerati post it on their blog with a link to this popcorn page; then you would be more likely to improve position. Maybe send it out to e-mail marketing sites/blogs so they can talk about it. The commotion might lead to some links. So, think about how you can tie this strategy into people linking to your site. People love to talk about stuff online and provide links, so the opportunities are out there.

    1. Post

      Hi Jeff,

      Your comment about how this might influence future personalized search for email recipients is excellent.  I hadn’t thought of that scenario.

      With regards to whether click-throughs factor into Google’s algorithm I’m posting this line from

      “Click through rate in natural search could be a factor in Google’s secret-sauce ranking algorithm. SEOmoz estimates click through to account for 7% according to its Search Engine Ranking Factors.” [link:

      That said, I thought all your points were excellent.  Thanks for contributing.

  6. Google has confirmed they do not take CTR into consideration into rankings. Instead of doing the aboe mentioned campaign, it they did something else like giving away free popcorn for their customers who wrote a blog post and link backed with the proper anchor text, that would be much more effective.

    1. Post
  7. This is actually very interesting, thank you for spreading it. Remember to also pay a visit to our web site. We’re an organization that offers Search engine optimization services, Web Site Design, Made to order Computer software Development and IT ideas in Philadelphia.

If the comment section remains empty I'm going to lose my job

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The maximum upload file size: 50 MB. You can upload: image. Links to YouTube, Facebook, Twitter and other services inserted in the comment text will be automatically embedded. Drop file here