Converting First-Time Buyers

The #1 question in the minds of first-time buyers is, “Why should I trust this company?”

This is where the power of storytelling comes in. Making your story 20% more persuasive will directly improve first-time buyer conversions by 20%. We’ve tested this on at least 50 ecommerce sites.

Let’s get one thing out of the way, when we say storytelling we’re not talking about fabricating facts. Every product innovation has a compelling origin story. Unfortunately, creators are so close to it they forget how special it is. They don’t think it’s relevant to talk about the 38 times their prototype failed. They don’t feel comfortable nerding out about their passion. But these are precisely the things your audience is looking to connect over. 

Anatomy of a compelling story:

— Show how this was a personal struggle. Your site visitors are struggling with a problem (that’s what brought them to you). Knowing their struggle is your #1 concern will draw them in.

— Let readers know they aren’t alone. 100s, 1000s, millions have the same struggle.

— Prove that your passion goes beyond just making the next buck. If Jon Favreau said, “I’m so excited about Mandalorian, it’s going to make me so much money” we’d be super turned off and it would cause statistically significant financial ruin. Instead, what Jon Favreau will likely say is, “We’re so excited to explore a new storyline in the Star Wars saga. I’m inspired by some of the same things that inspired George Lucas.”

— Demonstrate value for money. Whether you’ll selling a low-cost solution or a premium one your target audience demands value for money. So prove it.

— Prove that you designed your solution after considering all other available options and how your solution is the best for a very specific audience. The last thing frustrated shoppers want to do is to research more companies. By gently suggesting that you’ve done the due-diligence on competing solutions you’re giving the buyer a compelling reason to end their search and pull out their credit card.

— Prove to the reader that the buying power is with them. They need to feel they are driving the experience.

— Make the reader feel good about themselves.

— Make them feel smart.

— Show your human side. People buy from people they like. Show your humor, display vulnerability (“I failed 38 with 38 prototypes”, “at times I nearly gave up”), demonstrate that you’re trustworthy.